| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Technical Advances |
From the Departments of Pathology,*
University of Utah
Health Sciences Center and ARUP Institute for Clinical and Experimental
Pathology, Salt Lake City, Utah, and the Roger Williams Medical
Center
and Brown University School of
Medicine, Providence, Rhode Island
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
PCR assays have traditionally entailed a two-step procedure comprising an initial amplification reaction in a thermal cycler, followed by PCR product analysis in a separate process.6,8 Analysis of the PCR product has generally involved size fractionation by gel electro-phoresis and product visualization by ultraviolet (UV) transillumination of ethidium-bromide-stained gels or by radioisotopic detection. More recently, MBR gene rearrangements have been detected using fluorescently labeled primers during amplification, followed by a separate process of product detection by flow cytometric analysis9 or automated electrophoresis-based DNA sizing technology.10
PCR amplification with simultaneous amplicon analysis can be accomplished by incorporating a double-stranded DNA (dsDNA)-specific dye into amplification reactions carried out in glass capillary tubes.11 Fluorescence is monitored once per cycle after product extension, with the increase in fluorescence related to product accumulation. As the fluorescent dye indiscriminately detects all dsDNA, distinction of the PCR amplicon from the template, primer dimers, and other nonspecific dsDNA within the reaction solution is necessary. As the melting characteristics of any segment of dsDNA are specified by its GC content, length, and nucleotide sequence, determination of product identity can be achieved by virtue of its melting temperature.12
In this report, we present the detection of MBR/JH translocations using a rapid thermal cycler integrated with a microvolume fluorimeter that affords simultaneous thermal amplification and product identification by fluorescent melting curve analysis in less than 45 minutes. The product identity was confirmed as MBR/JH sequence in all of the 19 cases determined to be positive for the MBR/JH translocation product by fluorescence PCR. Our findings indicate that this method is a faster and more sensitive means of detection of MBR/JH translocations than conventional methods involving gel electrophoresis and has potential for improving turn-around time in the diagnostic laboratory.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
A total of 30 DNA samples previously assessed for the presence of the MBR/JH translocation by conventional PCR6 were randomly pulled from the files of the molecular diagnostics laboratories of the Roger Williams Medical Center, Providence, RI, and ARUP Laboratories, Salt Lake City, UT. These samples were assigned arbitrary code numbers to ensure unbiased evaluation and comparison with the results obtained using fluorescence melting-curve-based detection of the PCR products. These samples were composed of 19 known MBR/JH-positive cases, one of which was positive for the MBR/JH translocation by conventional PCR and contained Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) DNA sequences. We also examined 11 MBR/JH-negative cases, 6 of which were known to be positive for EBV DNA by PCR. DNA was also extracted from the well characterized SUDHL-6 cell line with a known MBR/JH6 translocation for dilution assays.
Conventional PCR Analysis
PCR analysis for MBR/JH translocations was performed as previously described.6,8,13 PCR assays designed to detect EBV DNA14 were performed to exclude the errant detection of EBV sequences by MBR/JH PCR as previously described.15 PCR products were subjected to electrophoresis in a 1.5% agarose gel (SeaKem LE agarose, FMC Bioproducts, Rockland, ME) containing 1X Tris-buffered ethanolamine and 0.5 µg/ml ethidium bromide. Amplification reactions containing a discrete band at the expected electrophoretic migration were considered to be positive (80 to 300 bp), using the Biomarker Low DNA ladder with band sizes of 1000, 700, 525/500, 400, 300, 200, and 100 bp as the DNA size marker (Bioventures, Murfreesboro, TN). The sensitivity of the conventional MBR/JH PCR with subsequent gel electrophoresis method was assessed using an initial concentration of 50 ng/µl of the MBR/JH-positive SUDHL-6 cell line DNA with serial dilutions of 1:2, 1:5, 1:10, 1:50, 1:100, 1:200, 1:300, 1:400, 1:500, and 1:1000 into placental DNA.
PCR and Fluorescence Melting Curve Analysis
Rapid cycle PCR analysis was performed with paired oligonucleotide
primers specific for the major breakpoint region of the bcl-2 gene (5'
GAG TTG CTT TAC GTG GCC TG 3', which binds to the MBR at the 3' UTR of
the bcl-2 gene at bp 2997 to 3016)8
and the JHa region of
the immunoglobulin heavy chain joining region (5' ACC TGA GGA GAC GGT
GAC C 3'), in a microvolume fluorimeter (LightCycler, Idaho Technology,
Idaho Falls, ID).16
Briefly, 50 ng of purified DNA was
amplified in a 10-µl reaction in glass capillary tubes containing 50
mmol/L Tris (pH 8.5), 3.0 mmol/L MgCl2, four
deoxynucleotide triphosphates at 200 µmol/L each, primers at 0.5
µmol/L, and 0.4 U of Taq DNA polymerase (Promega, Madison,
WI) with 11 ng/µl TaqStart antibody (ClonTech, Palo Alto, CA) per
10-µl sample. A hot start technique was used in all assays (94°C
for 1.5 minutes) followed by 45 cycles of denaturation (94°C for 10
seconds), annealing (68°C for 0 seconds), and extension (74°C for
20 seconds). Each reaction included SYBR Green I (1:30,000 dilution;
Molecular Probes, Eugene, OR), which interacts with all dsDNA. In the
LightCycler, filtered excitation light (450 to 490 nm) from a
blue-light-emitting diode is reflected from a 505-nm epi-illumination
dichroic filter and focused on the capillary tip where samples are
interrogated by paraxial epi-illumination. A proportion of the
excitation light is conducted up the capillary tube by total internal
reflection at the glass air interface. Emitted light is similarly
conducted down the capillary tube, exits via the tip and is filtered
through a 520- to 560-nm interference filter and focused onto silicon
photodiodes for detection. Data acquisition is achieved using Labview
graphical programming language (National Instruments, Austin, TX) with
a 12-bit multifunction input-output card in a 120-MHz Pentium
microcomputer (Intel, Santa Clara, CA).16
Fluorescence
signals were obtained once in each cycle by sequential monitoring of
fluorescence of each tube for 70 milliseconds at the end of extension.
All runs included a negative DNA control (normal human tonsil),
positive control (SUDHL-6 cell line DNA), and a control without
template. PCR amplification was performed under identical conditions
with primers specific for the human ß-globin gene to confirm the
amplifiability of the sample DNA. The forward primer sequence was 5'
GGC TTC CTA GAG ACC AAT CA 3' (GenBank accession U01317, bases 47693 to
47712), and the reverse primer sequence was 5' AAC CAA GAC AGC CAG TTC
AC 3' (GenBank accession U01317, bases 47780 to 47799). Multiplex PCR
was also performed using both the bcl-2/JH primers and the ß-globin
primers in the same reaction to demonstrate the specificity of the
fluorescence melting characteristics of the different products in the
same reaction. After PCR amplification, the PCR products were cooled to
45°C and then slowly heated to 100°C at a rate of 0.2°C per
second. For easier visualization of the melting temperatures,
fluorescence melting peaks were derived from the initial fluorescence
melting curves (F versus T) by plotting
the negative derivative of fluorescence over temperature
versus temperature (-dF/dT versus
T). Fluorescence PCR analysis was also performed using
serial dilutions of SUDHL-6 DNA as described above for conventional
PCR. The melting temperatures for both the MBR/JH and ß-globin PCR
products were also calculated using the equation
Tm = 81.5 + A + 0.41 x (% G/C)
- (500/bp), where A = 16.6 x
log10{[Salt]/(1 + 0.7 x [Salt], and [Salt]
= [Na+] + 4[Mg2+ - dNTP]0.5 +
[Tris+] (Tm is melting
temperature, and bp is length of product).17
Both the
calculated and observed Tm values for each
sample are presented in Table 1
.
|
Multiplex PCRs were performed using MBR and JH primers as well as the ß-globin primers as stated above for fluorescence MBR/JH PCR.
DNA Sequencing and Analysis
DNA sequencing analysis was performed on all 19 cases showing
positive fluorescence signals for the MBR/JH product (Table 1)
. The PCR
amplification products for DNA sequencing were purified and
concentrated using a Microcon-30 microconcentrator (Amicon, Beverly
MA). Template DNA concentrations were determined by absorbance at 260
nm. The purified PCR products were directly sequenced using the same
primers as for the MBR/JH PCR reactions on the ABI PRISM 377 with dye
terminators (PE Applied Biosystems, Foster City, CA). The identity of
the PCR product sequences was confirmed using the BLAST NCBI database.
Dilution Analyses
Dilutional assays were performed using serial dilutions of the MBR/JH-positive SUDHL-6 DNA, starting with 50 ng/µl as the initial template concentration. Fluorescence melting curves, relative fluorescence versus cycle number plots, and the area under the curves of fluorescence melting peaks were monitored.
Statistical Analysis
The empirically determined and calculated Tm values for each of the 19 positive samples were analyzed using the paired two-tailed Student's t-test, which indicated that there was no statistically significant difference between both sets of data (P = 0.8164).
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
ß-Globin PCR
All 30 cases analyzed yielded the expected 107-bp ß-globin
product by conventional PCR as well as the characteristic decline in
fluorescence (Figure 1A)
and fluorescence
melting peak at 81.2°C by fluorescence PCR indicating adequate DNA
integrity for PCR (Figure 1b)
. The expected Tm
of the ß-globin product was calculated to be 80.8°C using the
equation described above.
|
All 19 cases with MBR/JH rearrangements determined by conventional
PCR and gel electrophoresis showed an abrupt decline in fluorescence
signal (F) at 88.85 ± 1.15°C on the F
versus T curves (Figure 2A)
. A corresponding melting peak was
evident at 88.85 ± 1.15°C on the -dF/dT
versus T graphs in all cases with the MBR/JH
translocation product (Figure 2B
illustrates a case with
Tm of 90°C). All positive and negative
controls gave appropriate results. The 11 cases that were negative for
the translocation by conventional PCR were also negative by
fluorescence PCR. These results indicate a perfect correlation between
the findings on conventional PCR and gel electrophoresis and
fluorescence PCR.
|
Fluorescence melting curve analysis of multiplex PCR using MBR and
JH primers as well as ß-globin primers in the same reaction revealed
sharp declines in fluorescence and the appropriate fluorescence melting
peaks at 81.2°C and 90°C, corresponding to the specific
amplification products of ß-globin and MBR/JH, respectively (Figure 3)
.
|
Dilutional assays were performed using serial dilutions of the
MBR/JH-positive SUDHL-6 DNA; starting with 50 ng/10-µl reaction as
the initial template concentration. Fluorescence melting curves,
relative fluorescence versus cycle number plots and the area
under the curves of fluorescence melting peaks were analyzed.
Examination of the fluorescence profiles derived from five
amplification reactions consisting of sequential decreases in initial
template concentration (ie, 50, 5, 0.5, 0.1, and 0.05 ng, all in
10-µl amplification reactions) revealed that the cycle number at
which logarithmic amplification was noted was inversely related to the
starting copy number of template (data not shown). At low initial
template copy numbers, quantitation is difficult because of the
formation of and inability to distinguish undesired products. However,
melting peak analysis permitted the discrimination of the desired
MBR/JH product from primer dimers at initial template concentrations as
low as 0.05 ng in a 10-µl reaction (Figure 4A)
.
|
EBV-PCR
EBV DNA was demonstrable by PCR analysis in 7 of the 30 DNA
samples examined (Table 1)
. Six of the EBV-positive samples were
obtained from hyperplastic lymphoid tissues and were negative for
MBR/JH PCR by both conventional and fluorescence PCR, supporting the
specificity of the fluorescence PCR method. One case (case 15) was
positive for junctional MBR/JH sequences and contained EBV viral genome
but yielded only a fluorescence curve with Tm
characteristic of the MBR/JH product Tm (88.6°C; Table 1
).
Sequence Analysis
Bidirectional DNA sequencing confirmed the presence of the MBR/JH translocation in the 19 cases detected by fluorescence melting curve analysis.
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
In this study, we demonstrate the feasibility of using DNA melting
curves for the detection of MBR/JH translocations without employing
fluorescently labeled probes. Although SYBR Green I exhibits
nonspecific binding to dsDNA species other than the specific MBR/JH
product, the fluorescence signal obtained from primer dimers is of a
substantially lower melting point and is thus readily distinguishable
from that of the desired PCR product (Figures 2B and 4A)
. The
relationship between Tm, GC content, and DNA
length is evidenced by the lower Tm (~81°C)
of the ß-globin PCR product, which has a shorter length (107 bp) and
a lower GC content (40.4%) than the MBR/JH product with a higher
Tm (~90°C), greater length (mean, 190.4 bp),
and higher GC content (mean, 56.18%).
Similar to the detection of MBR/JH by the migration of the PCR products
within an expected size range, fluorescence PCR yields products over a
temperature range (88.85 ± 1.15°C). This also reflects the fact
that different products result from the juxtaposition of different MBR
breakpoints to JH region sequences (Figure 2C)
. Unlike agarose gel
electrophoresis, however, fluorescence melting curve analysis can
sometimes discriminate between products of almost identical size but
with different GC content (Table 1
, samples 1 and 3).
Inadvertent amplification of unintended sequences is a potential pitfall of PCR. Of relevance to MBR/JH PCR, a commonly used MBR primer (bases 2992 to 3011 in the bcl-2 gene) contains nine sequential bases that are also present in the EBV genome at its 3' end, with 14 oligonucleotides matching in total.15 In addition, the JH primer also contains nine sequential complementary bases to the EBV genome with 14 matching bases overall. Both primers show greatest sequence homology with the EBV genome at their 3' ends, which is most crucial for specific primer annealing and the subsequent extension step.
To determine the specificity of the fluorescence PCR assay, we examined
six cases of known EBV-positive, t(14;18)-negative lymphoproliferative
disorders using a similar MBR primer (bases 2997 to 3016 in the bcl-2
gene, with a total of 15 bases with homology to the EBV genome) and a
consensus JH primer. In all cases, the characteristic melting peak at
88.85 ± 1.15°C was absent, indicating specificity of the assay for
MBR/JH product. We also examined a case of MBR/JH-positive FCL that
also contained EBV genome (case 15). Fluorescence PCR analysis revealed
a PCR product with Tm of 88.6°C, and DNA
sequencing analysis confirmed that the product contained only MBR/JH
junctional sequences, further verifying assay specificity (Table 1)
.
Our fluorescence PCR method features a high annealing temperature
68°C for 0 seconds, which discourages any nonspecific
hybridization between the primers and an irrelevant template. In the
unlikely event that unintended sequences are amplified at such a high
annealing temperature, the melting characteristics of the resulting
product would be different from that obtained for the MBR/JH product
and thus easily distinguished. Multiplex PCR assays using both MBR/JH
and ß-globin primers also demonstrate the specificity of fluorescence
melting peak analysis (Figure 3)
. Comparison of conventional PCR
followed by gel electrophoresis with fluorescence PCR analysis reveals
that melting curve analysis identifies MBR/JH product at much lower
initial template concentrations than with ethidium-bromide-stained gels
(Figure 4, a and b)
. When compared with 5' exonuclease-based assays
using sequence-specific probes, the dynamic range of fluorescence
monitoring using DNA binding dyes is limited by nonspecific detection
of undesired products at very low template concentration and after
excessive PCR cycling.11,20
Whereas bcl-2/JH fusion sequences have been detected in the peripheral blood of healthy individuals21 and in hyperplastic lymphoid tissues,22 none of the cases of reactive lymphoid hyperplasia examined in our study yielded a positive fluorescence signal for MBR/JH junctional sequences. This may be attributed to the comparatively low initial template DNA concentration (50 ng/reaction) used in our assays. Nevertheless, we recommend correlation of genetic studies with histopathological and clinical findings before primary diagnosis of FCL is rendered. In cases in which recurrence of the primary neoplasm is suspected on account of detection of MBR/JH sequences, it is advisable to examine the clonal relatedness of sequential lymphomas by DNA sequencing analysis.
In conclusion, we have demonstrated that fluorescence melting peak analysis is a rapid, inexpensive, and accurate method for the detection of MBR/JH translocations. This method permits the simultaneous amplification, detection, and quantification of the specific PCR product over a broad range of initial template concentration. The simplicity and rapidity of this method render it very attractive for routine use in other spheres of molecular pathology.
| Footnotes |
|---|
Accepted for publication September 25, 1998.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
N. Pennell, A. Woods, M. Reis, R. Buckstein, D. Spaner, K. Imrie, K. Hewitt, A. Boudreau, A. Seth, and N. L. Berinstein Association of Clinical Status of Follicular Lymphoma Patients after Autologous Stem Cell Transplant and Quantitative Assessment of Lymphoma in Blood and Bone Marrow as Measured by SYBR Green I Polymerase Chain Reaction J. Mol. Diagn., February 1, 2006; 8(1): 40 - 50. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C. P. Vaughn and K. S. J. Elenitoba-Johnson High-Resolution Melting Analysis for Detection of Internal Tandem Duplications J. Mol. Diagn., August 1, 2004; 6(3): 211 - 216. [Abstract] [Full Text] |
||||
![]() |
K. S. J. Elenitoba-Johnson and S. D. Bohling Solution-Based Scanning for Single-Base Alterations Using a Double-Stranded DNA Binding Dye and Fluorescence-Melting Profiles Am. J. Pathol., September 1, 2001; 159(3): 845 - 853. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
G. G. Donohoe, M. Laaksonen, K. Pulkki, T. Ronnemaa, and V. Kairisto Rapid Single-Tube Screening of the C282Y Hemochromatosis Mutation by Real-Time Multiplex Allele-specific PCR without Fluorescent Probes Clin. Chem., October 1, 2000; 46(10): 1540 - 1547. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
T. C. Greiner Advances in Molecular Hematopathology : T-Cell Receptor {gamma} and bcl-2 Genes Am. J. Pathol., January 1, 1999; 154(1): 7 - 9. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |