| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
Regular Articles |


From the Department of Biological Sciences,*
University
of Massachusetts, Lowell, Massachusetts; the Department of Pathology
and Laboratory Medicine,
University of
Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania; and the Department of
Internal Medicine,
University of Iowa, Iowa
City, Iowa
| Abstract |
|---|
|
|
|---|
| Introduction |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Studies of the early stages of NFD in human autopsy material suggest that abnormal tau deposits develop in a stereotyped spatiotemporal sequence, with the earliest changes being seen in the distal dendrites of vulnerable neurons,8,9 and the appearance of evenly distributed, granular tau deposits that have been phosphorylated at the AT8/Tau-1 site.8,10 Throughout time, large deposits of filamentous, highly phosphorylated tau (NFTs) fill the somata of such neurons, which eventually die, leaving extracellular tombstone NFTs consisting of highly modified tau filaments.8,10 Unfortunately, very little is known concerning the time course and the precise sequence of cellular events required to produce these lesions in vivo. The total time required for NFT formation and neuronal death can only be determined indirectly from autopsy studies, and such estimates vary from several months to up to 20 years.11-13 In particular, it is unclear which of the observed cellular changes play early, causal roles in the cascade of events leading to NFD, and which are merely consequences of more central events. For instance, both axonal14 and dendritic8,15 degeneration are widespread in Alzheimers disease and other neurofibrillary degenerative conditions, yet it is unknown whether one or the other of these loci is the primary point of attack in NFD or if both dendritic and axonal changes are secondary to pathology affecting the entire cell. Similarly, it is unclear if NFD is primarily a cell-autonomous process, affecting only the cell containing the developing tangle, or if trans-synaptic mechanisms play a critical role. Finally, it is still unclear if the development of argyrophilia and/or tau phosphorylation at any one site plays a significant role in NFT formation and neurofibrillary degeneration in vivo, and if so, whether these changes are a cause or consequence of the polymerization of tau into filaments. The inability of neuropathologists to address these questions directly and effectively is primarily because of the impracticality of following individual neurons in which NFTs are developing on a prospective basis in humans and/or murine or other mammalian models in situ.16-18
Throughout the past few years, we have developed a unique cellular model of tau filament/NFT formation for studying the cytopathological changes that accompany chronic overexpression of human tau that circumvents many of the difficulties outlined above. This cellular model of tau-induced NFD consists of giant neurons [anterior bulbar cells (ABCs)] in the hindbrain of the ammocoete sea lamprey, Petromyzon marinus, that have been induced to overexpress human tau by the injection of plasmids containing constructs in which tau expression is driven by the cytomegalovirus (CMV) promoter. With this system, we showed for the first time that overexpression of the shortest human tau isoform (htau23) in vivo can cause the incorporation of human tau into filaments, the phosphorylation of the PHF1 and Tau1 epitopes (serines 396 to 404 and 199 to 202, respectively), and gross degenerative changes in the soma and dendrites including the externalization of human tau deposits.19 We have since characterized the intracellular behavior of human tau filaments in ABC somata and dendrites and their association with dendritic microtubule (MT) and synapse loss.20
In the present study, we have performed a systematic analysis of the degenerative changes caused by tau overexpression throughout time in ABCs, and have correlated these changes both with the length of time after vector injection and with the appearance of multiple AD-related epitopes on tau, including the PHF1, AT8, AT100, TG3, and ALZ50 sites, in ABCs expressing human tau. We have also compared the cytopathological changes induced by the longest human tau isoform (htau40) to those caused by htau23, and have compared htau23 and htau40 constructs containing Green Fluorescent Protein (GFP) fusions to those that express htau23 and htau40 alone. Finally, we have used a novel method of overexpressing tau in ABCs using self-replicating mRNAs derived from Semliki Forest Virus (SFV) to achieve chronic tau overexpression in ABCs in addition to the plasmid injection method used previously. We show that chronic overexpression of all of these constructs in ABCs induces the same stereotyped sequence of cytodegenerative changes throughout time, with the earliest and most severe changes occurring in the distal-most dendrites. Moreover, this sequence of degenerative changes is spatiotemporally correlated with the appearance of several AD-related phosphoepitopes. However, only the phosphorylation of the PHF1 epitope accompanies or precedes the earliest morphological changes induced by human tau overexpression in ABCs. These results bear a strong resemblance to sequences of cellular degeneration proposed for human NFD,8,10 and their significance and implications for the cellular mechanisms responsible for human NFD is discussed.
| Materials and Methods |
|---|
|
|
|---|
All constructs used in this study are shown in Figure 1A
. The human tau sequence was either
fused with the coding sequence for GFP at the tau N terminal (for
htau23clone 9320
) or at the tau C terminal (for
htau40clone 139) as shown in Figure 1A
. The plasmid
pRC/CMVn123c19
was used to overexpress htau23 without an
epitope tag. Htau40 was expressed without an epitope tag by
injecting mRNA purified by standard methods from the SFV-htau40 vector
into ABCs as described in Figure 1B
. Human tau expression was driven by
the CMV promoter as a single transcript in all of the constructs used.
|
Plasmid microinjection was performed as described,19 and surgery and preparation for fixation and immunohistochemistry was performed as described in Hall and Kosik.21 Briefly, the hindbrains of anesthetized ammocoete lampreys 8 to 11 cm in length were exposed and the somata of ABCs identified and injected under visual guidance. The brain was maintained under a constant flow of Ca++-free lamprey Ringers solution22,23 at all times, and the membrane potential of injected ABCs was monitored during injection. Microinjection of SFV-derived constructs was performed using a technique similar to that used for plasmids, but with modifications to ensure RNase-free conditions (ie, autoclaving of all stock solutions, electrode holder caps and electrode glass; addition of diethyl pyrocarbonate to stock solutions). In addition, the shanks of all micropipettes used for microinjecting SFV mRNAs were briefly flamed and allowed to cool before use. Otherwise, surgical procedures for all operations were identical to those described above and in Hall and Kosik.22 All procedures were performed under general anesthesia, which was accomplished by immersing the lampreys in a saturated aqueous solution of benzocaine for 10 to 20 minutes. Approximately 120 lampreys were used in this study, yielding 97 expressing cells. Sixty-seven of these cells produced 10-µm sections through their somata and dendritic trees that were immunostained with PHF1, and were thus considered suitable for staging purposes (see Results).
Electron Microscopy
Fixation, embedding, and sectioning was done as described in Hall
et al.19
Targeting of expressing ABCs was done by using
the features of the brain visible in the block provided by photographs
similar to that shown in Figure 2
as
visual cues. ABC dendrites in mildly degenerated cases were identified
by established morphological criteria for identifying distal dendrites
of axotomized ABCs in transverse thin sections through the lamprey
hindbrain.22,23
In sections processed for immunoelectron
microscopy, lamprey brains were fixed for 2 hours in 4%
paraformaldehyde/0.05% glutaraldehyde in 0.1 mol/L cacodylate buffer,
pH 7.4, and then transferred to phosphate-buffered saline containing 2
mol/L sucrose/0.2 mol/L glycine for 30 minutes followed by immersion in
liquid nitrogen. Frozen ultrathin sections were then cut at -120°C
with a cryo-diamond knife and transferred to Formvar-coated grids.
Immunolabeling was performed on the grids by standard methods with
0.5% fish skin gelatin (Sigma Chemical Co., St. Louis, MO) as a
blocking agent. A 1:10 dilution of anti-GFP antiserum (Clontech, Palo
Alto, CA) was then used to identify tau filaments. Protein
A-gold/anti-rabbit secondary (10 nm, Sigma) was then used to label
filaments for the electron microscopy. Grids were then stained in 0.3%
uranyl acetate for 10 minutes at 0°C and examined on a JEOL 1200EX
electron microscope.
|
Lamprey brains were fixed and sectioned as described.22 Immunocytochemistry was performed on 10-µm transverse sections of paraffin-embedded lamprey heads that had been fixed by immersion in FAA (10% formalin, 10% glacial acetic acid, and 80% ethanol). The mAbs PHF1 (1:100), ALZ50 (1:25), TG3 (1:25), AT8 (1:100), and AT100 (1:100) were used to identify phosphoepitopes on htau23 and htau40. PHF1, ALZ50, and TG3 were kindly provided by Dr. Peter Davies (Department of Pathology, Albert Einstein College of Medicine, Bronx, NY), and AT8 and AT100 were purchased from Innogenetics Corp. (Leuven, Belgium). None of these mAbs cross-reacted with endogenous epitopes in FAA-fixed lamprey brain. Sections were deparaffinized in Histoclear and then photographed if they contained fluorescent profiles of ABC somata and dendrites. They were then rehydrated, quenched in excess H2O2, washed, and incubated with primary overnight at 4°C. Biotinylated secondary antibodies were then applied and antibody staining revealed with an Biotin/Extravidin/HRP kit (Sigma Chemical Co.), with diaminobenzidine as the chromagen.
| Results |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The Earliest Changes Because of Human Tau Overexpression Appear in the Distal Dendrites of ABCs and Occur before Tau Hyperphosphorylation
Lightly expressing ABCs (Figure 2C)
and cells examined within a
few days of plasmid injection often showed no 10cytopathological
changes at all.19
These cells showed PHF1/GFP staining in
a granular, evenly distributed pattern throughout their somata and
dendrites, and did not label with any of the other mAbs directed at tau
phosphoepitopes (ie, AT8, TG3, AT100) or with ALZ50. Most of these
cells exhibited slight swelling of some distal dendrites and many of
them tended to have stronger PHF1 staining in their distal-most
dendrites than elsewhere.19
Cellular profiles were
otherwise normal, and nuclei were tau-negative. No lightly expressing
ABCs exhibited clearly fibrillar deposits, but such cells frequently
showed heavier immunolabel localized to the plasma membrane, especially
in distal dendrites (Figure 2C)
. We observed a total of 30 cells
fitting this description, which were examined between 4 and 56 days
after vector injection.
Human Tau Hyperphosphorylation First Occurs in ABC Distal Dendrites and Somata, and Is Correlated with Dendritic Swelling and Beading
Sixty-seven ABCs examined between 8 and 79 days after mRNA or
plasmid injection were found to have expressed human tau heavily enough
so that clear alterations to their normal somatodendritic morphology
were evident. These alterations usually took the form of a pronounced
swelling and/or beading of most or all of their distal dendrites. When
examined in the electron microscope, swollen dendritic tips were found
to contain aggregations of membrane-bound organelles mixed with tau
filaments and some MTs (Figure 3
; also
see Hall et al 20
). Of the 63 cells immunostained with
mAbs directed against phosphoepitopes other than PHF1, 45 exhibited
immunolabeling of one or more of the following mAbs: ALZ50 (25 of 57
cells sampled) TG3 (13 of 36 cells sampled), AT100 (4 of 10 cells
sampled), or AT8 (24 of 57 cells sampled). These hyperphosphorylated
deposits were highly localized, occurring in either the soma and/or the
distal dendrites (Figure 4)
, except in
cells exhibiting severe degeneration, where they were distributed
throughout the cell (Figure 5)
. A typical
example of a somatic deposit of hyperphosphorylated human tau at a
relatively early stage of degeneration is shown in Figure 4
; examples
of distal dendritic deposits are shown in Figures 3 and 4
. Although
somatic hyperphosphorylated tau deposits tended to have a fibrillar
appearance (Figure 4)
, much of the distal dendritic staining seemed to
be localized to membranous structures. This was particularly true of
ALZ50 staining (see Figures 4 and 5B
), although examples of
ALZ50-positive fibrillar deposits were also found (Figure 4
, asterisk).
All of the mAbs used labeled both fibrillar and membranous structures.
Immunostaining for ALZ50, TG3, AT8, or AT100 appeared in the distal
dendrites of 10 cells that did not exhibit somatic hyperphosphorylated
tau deposits, whereas only two cells were found that exhibited the
reverse pattern, suggesting that distal dendritic changes involving tau
hyperphosphorylation usually precede the onset of somatic tau
hyperphosphorylation. Proximal dendrites were hardly ever labeled with
any phosphoepitope-specific mAb other than PHF1 unless cytodegenerative
changes were present throughout the cell as well (Figure 5)
. There was
no clear temporal sequence of immunolabeling of human tau deposits with
the four mAbs that were used to identify hyperphosphorylated tau
deposits. Although ALZ50 was the only PHF-tau marker other than PHF1
recognizing tau in some ABCs, TG3 and/or AT8 staining appeared to
precede ALZ50 in others. Moreover, there was no significant difference
between the proportions of cells labeling with each mAb (other than
PHF1), suggesting that the events triggering the onset of
hyperphosphorylation may make each of these epitopes equally likely to
appear.
|
|
|
Progressive Degeneration of the Proximal Dendrites and Soma Is Spatiotemporally Correlated with Human Tau Hyperphosphorylation
Thirty ABCs showed more extensive and severe degeneration than
that described above, exhibiting degenerative changes involving
proximal as well as distal dendrites. In these cases, tau
hyperphosphorylation was also extended to these regions (Figure 5)
. In
most of these cells, extracellular human tau deposits that
immunolabeled with PHF1 were also visible (see Hall et
al19
and Figures 2E and 5C
). These deposits were clearly
located outside of the ABC plasma membrane, but some immunostaining
appeared to be in the extracellular space (Figure 5A)
whereas other
deposits appeared to be inside of ependymal and/or glial cells (Figure 5, E and F)
. Some extracellular tau deposits also labeled with TG3,
ALZ50, or AT8, but usually less extensively than with PHF1. Such cells
exhibited beading, distortion, and loss of dendrites throughout the
dendritic field. As with the milder cases of degeneration described
above, human tau deposits in severely degenerated ABCs appeared to be
either membranous or fibrillar, with the former predominating in
dendritic tips and the latter most prominent in the soma and proximal
dendrites. There was no sign that immunolabeling of any epitope (other
than PHF1) was more widespread or intense than the others.
We found that these severely degenerated ABCs (in which the entire soma
and dendritic field was involved) could be divided into relatively mild
cases, in which the nucleus was still present and the somatodendritic
profile was still clearly defined, and the most severe cases, where the
expressing ABCs no longer exhibited a recognizable nucleus or a
continuous plasma membrane. Axonal profiles were still present in most
cases and often appeared grossly normal, although extracellular PHF1
staining was occasionally found around axonal profiles (not shown).
Nuclei, when present, were invariably tau immunopositive, unlike their
appearance in milder cases of tau-induced degeneration (Figures 2E, 5A, and 5C
, asterisks).
Proposed Staging of Tau-Induced Neurodegeneration in ABCs
To determine whether the differences between mildly and severely
degenerated ABCs described above were because of a progressive sequence
of degenerative changes over time, we re-examined sections from all of
the ABCs used in this study and assigned each to a stage of
neurofibrillary degeneration based entirely on morphological criteria.
We used only cells that had either a PHF1- or GFP-immunolabeled slide
through their somata, proximal dendrites, and distal dendrites for
staging purposes. Sixty-seven of the 97 cells examined in this study
met these criteria and were staged as described below by a person who
was blind to the age and identity of each cell examined. We thus
specifically excluded the length of time that human tau was expressed
in ABCs and the presence of hyperphosphorylated tau as staging criteria
so as to test directly the relationship between the degree of
morphological degeneration of htau-expressing ABCs, their
phosphorylation state and time after injection. We broke down the
sequence of htau-induced neurofibrillary degeneration in ABCs into the
following intervals between major events that were characteristic of
all of the tau constructs used, which we then used as the basis of
assigning stages of degeneration: 1) the first detectable presence of
tau immunolabel up to the first noticeable changes from normal
morphology (usually mild swelling of some but not all distal
dendrites); 2) clear beading or swelling of all distal dendrites up to
the distortion and roughening of some proximal as well as distal
dendrites (cells showing extracellular tau label were excluded); 3)
clear involvement of the entire somatodendritic region, including
nuclear staining, pinching off or beading of entire dendrites, the
formation of fibrillar tau in proximal dendrites, and extracellular tau
deposits up to the visible breakdown of the plasma membrane; 4) clear
indications of cell death, including nuclear loss, fragmentation of the
plasma membrane and the cellular profile as a whole, and endocytosis of
human tau deposits by adjacent glial cells. These stages of
htau-induced degeneration, plus associated changes in tau
phosphorylation are summarized schematically in Figure 6
.
|
10 days each in stages 1 to 2, and somewhat longer in
stage 3. A clear positive correlation (P < 0.05
or better, chi-square test) between the time of human tau expression
and the stage of degeneration reached in ABCs was retained when the
cells were sorted according to: 1) tau isoform used, 2) the presence or
absence of an epitope tag, and 3) whether expression was achieved with
a plasmid or with the SFV mRNA vector (Figure 7B)
|
| Discussion |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Comparison of Neurofibrillary Degeneration in ABCs and Human NFD
The stages of neurofibrillary degeneration in ABCs exhibit
striking points of resemblance to the staging of neurofibrillary
changes in human hippocampal pyramidal cells proposed by Braak et
al,8
and Braak and Braak.9
These
investigators based their studies on autopsy material from persons who
did not show widespread neurofibrillary pathology, allowing them to
assign stages of cellular degeneration without reference to
extracellular or trans-synaptic influences. They found that
the mildest degree of degeneration featured the appearance of tau
immunostaining in an even, granular distribution throughout the soma
and dendrites, followed by the expansion and distortion of the
distal-most apical and basolateral dendrites. Stages 2 and 3 of Braak
et al,8
in which distal dendritic tufts show swelling,
distortion, and beading at the same time as fibrillar tau deposits (ie,
early NFTs) are forming in the somata of hippocampal pyramidal cells,
closely resemble stage 2 in ABCs (Figure 4)
. More severe stages of
degeneration in the hippocampus, as in ABCs, feature the breakdown of
somatic morphology, nuclear loss, and the appearance of extracellular
tau deposits. On the other hand, there are features of the NFD modeled
in ABCs that are not identical to human neurofibrillary disease. For
instance, the order of appearance of specific phosphoepitopes appears
to be somewhat different in ABCs and in incipient human NFD, with PHF1
rather than AT8 appearing throughout the cell at pretangle stages
(stages 1 and 2) in ABCs. AT8 appeared in tau-expressing ABCs only at a
time when morphological degeneration was widespread in the distal
dendrites, and did not precede overt morphological changes as they did
in the Braak study.8
Furthermore, Gallyas silver
impregnation and Thioflavin-S labeling were negative in all
tau-expressing ABCs examined (not shown), even when heavy filamentous
deposits were present., whereas most fibrillar tau deposits appeared to
be argyrophilic in the Braak study.8
This may have
something to do with the very different time scales involved in NFD in
humans (up to 20 years)12
) versus ABCs (weeks
or months at most)possibly the argyrophilia of NFTs in
vivo is acquired gradually by the slow accumulation of one of the
many NFT-associated substances found in human pathology. One possible
candidate for this role is intracellular Aß, which may serve to link
NFT formation to APP metabolism in Alzheimers
disease,24-27
and that has been put forward as a source
of Thioflavin-S birefringence in NFTs.27
It is interesting
to note in this context that the spatiotemporal pattern of human tau
hyperphosphorylation in ABCs presented in this study closely resembles
that of the development of argyrophilia in human hippocampal pyramidal
cells, with foci in the distal dendrites and somata spreading
eventually to most of the cell.8
It is thus tempting to
speculate that hyperphosphorylation might be a preliminary to the
development of argyrophilia, and that the latter fails to develop in
ABCs because of the accelerated time course of tau accumulation and
degeneration relative to that seen in human NFD.
A key advantage of being able to directly correlate the progression of degenerative stages with time in an in vivo cellular model system is that it became possible for the first time to compare the times of onset of several degenerative changes (tau hyperphosphorylation, dendritic swelling, dendritic degeneration, axonal loss) that are characteristic of neurofibrillary degeneration. The implications of our results for the interrelationships between these events in ABCs and in human NFD are discussed below.
Hyperphosphorylation and Neurofibrillary Degeneration in ABCs
Human tau has been induced to form filaments under a variety of
conditions in vitro28-33
and these studies
have suggested several possible mechanisms by which deposits of
filamentous tau might form in NFD. However, although there is abundant
in vivo and in vitro evidence that the
phosphorylation of human tau protein regulates its ability to bind to
and stabilize MTs,34-36
and good reason to suppose that
tau filament formation plays a critical role in tau-induced
cytodegeneration,19-20,37
there is no clear
evidence that the hyperphosphorylation of tau is required for either
tau filament formation in vivo or the cytodegeneration
caused by NFD. We showed in a previous study of tau-induced NFD in
ABCs20
that human tau forms large numbers of filaments
throughout ABC somata and dendrites by 10 days after plasmid injection,
at a time when all of the cells expressing that construct (clone
93htau23 with an N terminal fusion of EGFP) are in either stages 1 or
2 (see Figure 7A
). Because there is little if any tau
hyperphosphorylation outside of the distal-most dendrites before stage
3, it seems unlikely that tau hyperphosphorylation is prerequisite for
tau filament formation, at least in ABCs. Immunolabeling for PHF1
alone, by contrast, occurs very early after the onset of tau expression
in ABCs, and precedes the first morphological signs of degeneration.
Thus, it is possible that the phosphorylation of the PHF1 site (but not
other AD-related phosphoepitopes) is a necessary preliminary for tau
filament formation and consequent degenerative changes in ABCs.
Constitutive phosphorylation of the other AD-related sites might occur
as a consequence of filament formation, especially if the incorporation
of tau into filaments were to block access to tau phosphoepitopes by
phosphatases that normally dephosphorylate tau at these
sites.38,39
However, the tight association of tau
hyperphosphorylation with the progress of degenerative changes in ABCs,
murine, and ovine model systems,16-18
and human
tauopathies suggests that it plays an important but as yet obscure role
in NFD cytopathogenesis.
The Dendrites as an Initial Focus for Neurofibrillary Pathology
The other major implication of these data for the pathological mechanisms underlying NFD at the cellular level is the localization of the first pathological changes to the dendritic tips. This is particularly interesting in light of the membranous nature of most of the distal dendritic tau deposits and the involvement of membranous organelles in the swelling of dendritic tips that initiate the degeneration process in ABCs, and suggests a number of possible routes by which human tau overexpression might initiate a degenerative cascade. For instance, recent studies have implicated the N-terminal domain of human tau as a potential point of interaction between tau and the plasma membrane,40 and tau may also compete with kinesin in its interactions between membranous organelles and MTs under conditions where tau is overexpressed,41,42 leading to the disruption of kinesin-mediated transport of membranous organelles. Either of these interactions might plausibly lead to accumulations of membranous organelles both in the cell body and at dendritic tips, especially because dendritic MTs have mixed polarity.43
The contrast that we found between the time of onset of gross
morphological changes to dendritic tips and axons may also have
important implications for the issue of where the initial changes
leading to NFT formation and neurofibrillary degeneration occur in
human NFD. Our results lend some support to the proposal that
degenerative changes in the dendrites precede axonal degeneration in
NFD. Although the dendritic tips began to show PHF1 immunolabel and
signs of swelling during stage 1, overt changes to ABC axonal
morphology suggestive of degeneration were not seen until stage 3.
Normal looking axons were seen in a number of stage 2 to 3 cases that
were processed for electron microscopy, where dendritic degeneration
was later shown to be severe, with extensive MT and synapse
loss.20
This is in agreement with earlier work in this
system where the phosphorylation of both the PHF1 and Tau1 sites
appeared to occur in the sequence: distal dendrites
proximal
dendrites/soma
axon at early stages of degeneration.19
This sequence is later recapitulated in the pattern of both
hyperphosphorylation and cytodegeneration in stages 2 and 3. Thus a
direct interference with functions such as MT-mediated dendritic
transport by tau seems to be more plausible than an initial effect on
axonal function, which might be expected to cause early changes in
axonal morphology as well as dendritic changes.
It remains possible, however, that the observed dendritic changes were induced by an initial interference with normal axon function (such as an inhibition of axonal fast transport via an interaction of tau with kinesin) without obvious early effects on axonal morphology. Such an interaction (if strong enough) might cause the cell to react as if it had been axotomized. Because axotomy at a point very close to the soma can cause loss of normal neuronal polarity, with axonal sprouting from dendritic tips,44,45 this might account for the initial dendritic swelling in tau-expressing ABCs, especially as swollen dendritic tips are the first morphological change visible in ABCs after both close axotomy and tau overexpression. Polarity loss is a characteristic event in the cytopathology of Alzheimers disease as well as in axotomized ABCs,46,47 where massive dendritic sprouting gives rise to axon-like processes such as neuropil threads.48,49 No direct connection between polarity loss and axonal loss has yet been established in human NFD, although it should be noted that htau40 overexpression in mice has produced axonopathy in the absence of clear filamentous pathology, suggesting a possible early role for axonal dysfunction in tau-induced NFD in at least some cell types.18
Implication of These Findings for Interpreting the Role of Tau Mutations in Producing Human NFD
Finally, the observation that htau23 and htau40 produces virtually identical effects when overexpressed in ABCs has possible implications for understanding the roles played by the characteristic tau isoform differences between neurofibrillary lesions of clinically defined tauopathies50,51 and the mechanism of action of some tau mutations that induce NFD in humans. One of the most puzzling issues raised by the recent identification of mutations affecting the tau coding sequence and tau splicing has been the difficulty in accounting for the widely different neuropathology resulting from these mutations, some of which appear to merely change the relative frequency of tau isoforms with three versus four MT binding repeats.4,6,7,51 For instance, although we found that htau23 and htau40 produce patterns of degeneration that are indistinguishable from one another when overexpressed in ABCs, two recent reports of the effects of overexpressing htau2317 and htau4018 in mice showed quite different patterns of pathology. These differences emphasize the following points: 1) the likely importance of cell-type specificity in determining how the presence or absence of a particular tau isoform produces cell-type-specific susceptibility and patterns of neurofibrillary pathology in familial tauopathies, and 2) that the underlying cellular mechanisms responsible for tau-induced neurofibrillary degeneration are not isoform-dependent and depend on interactions between human tau and highly conserved mechanisms of neuronal physiology. Thus although the development of murine models that faithfully reproduce the characteristic pathological features associated with the various familial tauopathies will be essential for understanding their pathogenesis, there is also clearly a complementary need for further intensive study of the fundamental cell biological mechanisms responsible for tau-induced neurofibrillary degeneration at the level of a single, identified neuron. The large cell size, unique accessibility, and stereotyped morphology and physiology of ABCs should make them ideal for this purpose.
| Footnotes |
|---|
Supported by National Institutes of Health grant AG13909 to G. F. H.
Accepted for publication September 21, 2000.
| References |
|---|
|
|
|---|
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
P. Grant, Y. Zheng, and H. C. Pant Squid (Loligo pealei) Giant Fiber System: A Model for Studying Neurodegeneration and Dementia? Biol. Bull., June 1, 2006; 210(3): 318 - 333. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
J. AVILA, J. J. LUCAS, M. PEREZ, and F. HERNANDEZ Role of Tau Protein in Both Physiological and Pathological Conditions Physiol Rev, April 1, 2004; 84(2): 361 - 384. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
X. Roucou, Q. Guo, Y. Zhang, C. G. Goodyer, and A. C. LeBlanc Cytosolic Prion Protein Is Not Toxic and Protects against Bax-mediated Cell Death in Human Primary Neurons J. Biol. Chem., October 17, 2003; 278(42): 40877 - 40881. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
Z. Suo, M. Wu, B. A. Citron, R. E. Palazzo, and B. W. Festoff Rapid Tau Aggregation and Delayed Hippocampal Neuronal Death Induced by Persistent Thrombin Signaling J. Biol. Chem., September 26, 2003; 278(39): 37681 - 37689. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
M. Goedert Neurodegenerative tauopathy in the worm PNAS, August 19, 2003; 100(17): 9653 - 9655. [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
A. L. Guillozet, S. Weintraub, D. C. Mash, and M. M. Mesulam Neurofibrillary Tangles, Amyloid, and Memory in Aging and Mild Cognitive Impairment Arch Neurol, May 1, 2003; 60(5): 729 - 736. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||